A-Day students had their first formal Socratic Seminar today, finishing up the work we began with the counselors' lessons last week on bullying. Our introductory SS last week was on a playful, even silly topic: pizza toppings. While arguing for superiority of a given pizza topping was fun, and while the added challenge of arguing for a topping most of the group members likely hated (anchovies are not popular among sixth graders), the intent of the introductory exercise was to let students master the protocols of a Socratic Seminar without worrying about a heavy topic.

The students' discussions today ranged from the definition of bullying to the proper response to bullying, from why people might bully to scenarios to determine whether or not it's bullying. The discussion never strayed off topic, and even on the one occasion when it looked like a student was taking it off into deep left field, his clarification showed how it was indeed cogent.

More importantly in some ways was the fact that all students self-regulated and managed a very professional discussion. There was no interrupting; there was no arguing; there was no overly-aggressive verbal exchanges. Instead, it simply looked and sounded like a group of adults having a formal discussion. I joked that a lot of government bodies (congresses, parliaments, etc.) could have taken some lessons from these kids on how to have a calm, civil discussion.

Every single student met the requirements for an A, and all classes today were astonished not only that they'd conducted a discussion lasting half an hour with little to no input from me but also that it seemed to go by so very quickly. The fact that sixth graders sustained a 30-minute academic conversation essentially on their own says a lot about the growth they're already demonstrating.

In short, the seminar was successful not merely because students discussed bullying thoughtfully, but because they demonstrated independence, maturity, listening, and civil discourse.
B-Day students will have the same work tomorrow, and I fully expect it to be just as successful.

0 Comments